Don't have an account?
Save 15% on select gifts with code MIX15
Enjoy an incredible assortment of baked goods, from bagels and English muffins to flavorful loaf cakes and so much more.
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins - 4 Packages
available to ship now
Favorite Flavors Sampler
available to ship april 07 2025
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Traditional English Muffins Sampler
1910 Original Recipe Traditional English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins - 12 Packages
Super-Thick English Muffins - 5 Packages
Mix & Match Traditional English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Preserves and Fruit Butters - 3 Jars
Bakery Sampler Box
Mix & Match Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Mix & Match Bakery Gift - Pick 6
English Muffin Variety Assortment
Wolferman’s® Deluxe New York Bagel Sampler
Wolferman’s® Super-Thick English Muffin & New York Bagel Sampler
San Francisco-Style Sourdough Traditional English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mini English Muffins Sampler
Baker’s Dozen Super-Thick English Muffins
Wolferman’s® New York Bagel Sampler
Blueberry Traditional English Muffins - 6 Packages
Tearoom Scones Sampler
Loaf Cake Sampler
1910 Original Recipe Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Multi-Grain Honey Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
1910 Original Recipe Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
San Francisco-Style Sourdough Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Cheddar Cheese Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Wolferman’s® Super-Thick English Muffins and New York Bagels - Mix & Match Pick 6
Pumpkin Spice Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Italian Herb and Cheese Pull-Apart Bread
British Scones, Cream, and Conserves
Super-Thick English Muffins with Spreads
Cranberry Citrus Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Chocolate & Cinnamon Babka Duo
San Francisco-Style Sourdough Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins Gift Box with Tongs - 4 Packages
Gourmet Waffle Assortment
Bountiful Bakery Sampler Box
Mix & Match Mother’s Day Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Mix & Match Coffee Cakes
Mix & Match Loaf Cakes - 4 Packages
Mix & Match Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
Wolferman’s® Super-Thick English Muffins and New York Bagels - Mix & Match Pick 4
Muffin Master
Grand Bakery Gift Basket featuring Wolferman’s® New York Bagels
Cranberry Citrus Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Tearoom Scones - 12 Packages
Mix & Match Mother’s Day Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Davidovich Bakery New York Rainbow-Colored Bagels
Davidovich Muffins
Wolferman’s® New York Bagels with Spreads
Deluxe Assortment of Scones
Mix & Match Easter Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Wolferman’s® New York Bagels - Mix & Match Pick 4
Cardamom Rolls
Gourmet Butter Assortment
Wolferman’s® English Muffin & New York Bagel Gift Box
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins Gift Box with Tongs - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Sweet Rolls - 2 Trays
Mix & Match Thinking of You Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Deluxe Bakery Gift Basket featuring Wolferman’s® New York Bagels
Breakfast Entertainer Gift Basket
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffins Gift Box with Tongs - 12 Packages
Wolferman’s® New York Bagel Brunch
Davidovich Bakery Classic Bread Assortment
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Apple Cinnamon Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Doughnut Muffin Assortment
Deluxe Signature Bakery Tower
Focaccia Bread Assortment
Mix & Match Easter Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Delicious Mornings Gift Basket
Cinnamon Raisin Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Grand Berry Breakfast Box featuring Wolferman’s® New York Bagels
Wolferman’s® New York Bagels - Mix & Match Pick 6
Mix & Match Mother’s Day Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Wolferman’s® Super-Thick English Muffins and New York Bagels - Pick 12
1910 Original Recipe English Muffin Variety Assortment
Gluten-Free Lemon Poppyseed and Cinnamon Streusel Muffins
Blueberry Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
Cinnamon Raisin Mini English Muffins - 6 Packages
Cheesy Onion and Garlic Rolls
Gluten-Free Blueberry Muffins
Davidovich Bakery New York Rye Bread Duo
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Cherry Blossom Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Blueberry Super-Thick English Muffins - 6 Packages
Grand Signature Bakery Tower
Mix & Match Thinking of You Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Mix & Match Thinking of You Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Grand Mother’s Day Gift Basket
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Birthday Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Davidovich Bakery Sandwich Roll Assortment
Davidovich Bakery Dinner Roll Assortment
Gluten-Free Bagels
Sympathy Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Cinnamon Raisin Traditional English Muffins - 6 Packages
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Birthday Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Birthday Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Wolferman’s® New York Bagels - Mix & Match Pick 12
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Sympathy Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Mix & Match Thank You Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Mix & Match Thank You Bakery Gift - Pick 4
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Sympathy Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Mix & Match Super-Thick English Muffin Sympathy Bakery Gift - Pick 12
Davidovich Bakery New York Plain Bagels, Lox, and Cream Cheese
Mix & Match Thank You Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Revolution InstaGLO® R270 Toaster - Platinum
Harry & David
Davidovich Bakery New York Everything Bagels, Lox, and Cream Cheese
Sympathy Bakery Gift - Pick 6
Mix & Match Easter Bakery Gift - Pick 12